top of page

The Ultimate Guide to Selling Your Engagement Ring in NJ

Updated: May 9, 2023

A recent report indicates that people call off about 20% of engagements. While there are many different ways in which this decision can impact your life, it could also mean that you're left with an expensive engagement ring that you are no longer going to wear or use.

Selling your engagement ring to a buyer in your local area can be a great way to recoup some of your costs, which could help you move forward from this challenging time with your head held high. However, it's crucial that you work with a buyer you can trust to ensure you get as much cash as possible for your unwanted ring.

sell my engagement ring

Why You Must Sell Your Engagement Ring to a Reputable Buyer

As discussed above, when it comes to selling your engagement ring, it's crucial that you're able to find a reputable buyer. Otherwise, a buyer may take advantage of your trust, meaning you get less cash than you deserve.

You can assess a buyer's reputation suitably by reading customer reviews on Google or searching the company on the Better Business Bureau.

The Best Places for Selling Engagement Rings in New Jersey

If you live in New Jersey, there are many reputable buyers in the area to whom you can sell your engagement ring (alongside other unwanted jewelry). For example, this includes local jewelry buyers and stores.

However, American Gold and Diamond Buyers is undoubtedly the best place in New Jersey when you are looking to get a fair offer for the jewelry you bring in. This is because we're experts in the field and can carry out jewelry appraisals that assess how much the ring is worth - ensuring you get a fair price every time. That's why we currently have a 5-star rating on Google Reviews and consistently receive positive reviews from our clients.

How to Get the Most Cash for Your Ring

If you are looking to sell your unwanted engagement ring, there are a few steps you can follow to ensure you get as much cash as possible when leaving the store.

For example, you should:

Keep the Ring in Pristine Condition

The better maintained your engagement ring, the easier it will be to sell it for a reasonable price. For example, the price may drop slightly if your ring is dirty or scratched. As a result, you should clean the ring ahead of time. According to the Gemological Institute of America, diamond engagement rings "can be cleaned safely with lint-free cloths, commercial jewelry cleaning solutions, and household detergents."

Get Multiple Appraisals

Don't shake on the first appraisal you receive; try to get a fair few appraisals ahead of time. This way, you can take your ring to the company that offers you the best price.

Negotiate the Price

Once you know how much your jewelry is worth, you could increase the price a pawnbroker or buyer offers by relying on your negotiation skills.

How Can I Sell My Engagement Ring NJ?

The above guidance can be beneficial when selling your engagement ring in New Jersey (and further afield). Remember, you should:

  • Work to understand the appraisal process, and try to get as many appraisals as possible ahead of time.

  • Read reviews from previous customers to assess how trustworthy a buyer may (or may not) be.

  • Negotiate with your buyer to get the best possible price - feel free to walk away and hold your own, especially if you think their price is far too low.

The American Gold & Diamond Buyer team is here to help if you want to sell your engagement ring quickly. We can talk you through every step as you sell your unwanted engagement ring and ensure you get the best price for your jewelry.

We understand that selling your engagement ring can be a difficult and emotional experience, so we're here to make the process as straightforward and stress-free as possible. If you'd like to learn more, please do not hesitate to get in touch today.

Visit American Gold & Diamond Buyers

At American Gold & Diamond Buyers, we understand the emotional significance of an engagement ring and the importance of receiving a fair price. Our team of experienced professionals is committed to providing honest and transparent service to help you make an informed decision.

If you want to sell your engagement ring in NJ, we invite you to visit our website or contact us for a free consultation. Our knowledgeable staff will answer any questions and guide you through the process with care and respect.

Don't let the process of selling your engagement ring be a burden. Let American Gold & Diamond Buyers make it an easy and stress-free experience. Contact us today to get started.

american gold & diamond buyers


Diamond Ring


bottom of page