top of page

Turn Your Old Jewelry Into Cash: A Beginner's Guide

Did you know you may be sitting on a goldmine of cash regarding unwanted jewelry in your home?

Instead of letting your old rings, necklaces, and more sit around the house, you can turn them into cash by selling them to a reputable buyer in your local area or online. This can be particularly lucrative if you own any vintage pieces, especially as they are coming back in style again.

cash for jewelry

How to Identify Valuable Pieces of Jewelry

If you're looking to unload some of your jewelry, you must be able to determine which pieces are valuable and which are not. This will be useful when you take your items to a buyer, especially if you have to negotiate a price.

Fortunately, there are many different ways to figure out if your jewelry is valuable. For example, the item's worth could be dependent upon the following:

  • Whether or not it contains any precious metals or gemstones

  • The maker of the jewelry

  • How the item is crafted

  • The condition of the jewelry

As such, you should study each jewelry item carefully before taking it to a buyer to be as informed as possible. Buying guides, such as this gemstone buying guide from the Jewelers of America, may be valuable resources during this time, especially if you are still determining which gems are featured beforehand.

However, if you aren't city if what you have is valuable or not, don't worry. A good buyer, like American Gold & Diamond Buyers, should always be willing to take a look at your items and identify if what you have is valuable or not.

Different Types of Jewelry Buyers

Once you understand how much your jewelry is worth, you can take your items to a buyer for an appraisal. Again, there are many different avenues to explore here. For example, you could take them to a company such as American Gold & Diamond Buyers, a local jewelry-buying store, or submit photos to an online marketplace.

Each option has its own merits. For example, selling jewelry online is efficient as it means you don't need to leave the comfort of your home, and pawnshops are suitable for quick deals. However, selling to local buyers such as American Gold & Diamond Buyers is always the best choice. You'll often be given a much fairer price for your jewelry, in a much more comfortable setting, than at a pawnshop.

How to Prepare Your Jewelry for Sale

Before kickstarting the sales process, you must ensure your jewelry is in good condition - especially if it has been lying around your house for some time. Most jewelry can be cleaned safely using products you already have within your home. However, you should research the specific metals and gemstones featured within your items to avoid causing further damage or scratching the gems/diamonds. Alternatively, many jewelry buyers will clean your item for free (if needed to buy).

You should then take your jewelry to be appraised. This process is where an expert jeweler studies each item to determine its overall worth based on craftsmanship, materials used, and weight. This information is detailed in a simple document you can take to a buyer to help ensure you get a fair price.

You can find a reputable appraiser in your area by searching the National Association of Jewelry Appraisers website.

Tips for Negotiating the Best Price for Your Jewelry

If this is your first time selling jewelry, bartering or entering tough negotiations with your buyer may seem daunting - but it's a normal part of the buying and selling process. As such, you must enter the conversation with as much confidence as possible, as this will ensure you can come to a fair deal.

For example, one way you can negotiate a better deal is by conducting some research beforehand into the current market values of your jewelry. This way, you'll know if the offer they put on the table is fair or they are trying to undersell you.

Furthermore, you should also enter the negotiation with an idea of your bottom line (the least amount of money you'll take). While you should always aim to bring away more cash than this, knowing when to draw the line is useful.

How to Complete the Selling Process

Once you've discussed with your buyer and agreed upon a price, you must follow a few steps to complete the sales process. For example, you should gather all relevant paperwork, such as appraisal documents. You should then discuss different payment options with your buyer. For example, you may want to complete the process with a bank transfer or leave the cash in your hands!

Visit American Gold & Diamond Buyers

At American Gold & Diamond Buyers, we understand that jewelry can hold significant sentimental value, especially engagement rings. However, we also recognize the importance of receiving a fair price when selling your jewelry. Our team of experienced professionals is dedicated to providing honest and transparent service to help you make informed decisions.

If you want to sell your engagement ring or any other type of jewelry in NJ, we invite you to visit our website or contact us for a free consultation. Our knowledgeable staff will answer any questions and guide you through the process with care and respect.

Don't let the process of selling your jewelry become a burden. With our expert assistance, we can make it an easy and stress-free experience. Whether you're a beginner or have sold jewelry before, we're here to help. Contact us today to get started on turning your old jewelry into cash.

get your cash offer


Diamond Ring


bottom of page