Coins Worth Money in New Jersey: What to Look For & Where to Sell

Darryl Gaye
Apr 18
3 min read

Introduction: Surprising Value Hidden in Your Change Jar

Whether you've inherited a coin collection, stumbled on old coins while cleaning out an attic, or saved some unique change over the years, you might be holding onto something worth far more than face value. In New Jersey, many residents are discovering that certain coins—especially older or rare ones—can carry substantial collector or melt value.

In this post, we'll explain the types of coins that are worth money, how to assess their value and the best local options for selling them.

A close-up assortment of valuable U.S. coins including silver dollars, wheat pennies, and gold coins laid out on a wooden surface.

1. Valuable Coins Commonly Found in New Jersey

Here are some coins that New Jersey residents frequently bring in, which often turn out to be worth much more than expected:

Pre-1965 Silver Coins: Dimes, quarters, and half dollars minted before 1965 contain 90% silver and are valued for their melt content.
Indian Head Pennies (1859–1909): Especially those in better condition or with rare years like 1877.
Buffalo Nickels (1913–1938): Early years and those with full dates are collectible.
Morgan Silver Dollars (1878–1921) and Peace Dollars (1921–1935): High silver content and strong demand.
Wheat Pennies (1909–1958): While common, some rare mint marks can be valuable.
Error Coins: Coins with double strikes, off-center prints, or missing details can be worth hundreds or more.

2. How to Identify a Coin's Value

Not all old coins are valuable—but the right combination of condition, rarity, and demand can turn pocket change into real money.

Key factors:

Date & Mint Mark: The year and where it was minted (P, D, S, etc.) matter.
Condition (Grade): The better the condition, the more valuable. Professional grading services like PCGS or NGC can help.
Metal Content: Coins with silver or gold content are priced based on collectible and melt values.
Rarity: Limited mintage coins or coins with errors command premium prices.

Pro Tip: If unsure, bring your coins in for a free evaluation.

3. Where to Sell Coins in New Jersey

Once you know the value of your coins, you'll want to find a reputable local buyer.

Options to consider:

Local Coin Shops: Convenient, but pricing can vary.
Online Marketplaces: eBay, forums, or auctions can work, but require knowledge and time.
Local Precious Metal Buyers (like us): Fast, transparent offers from professionals who value both collectible and melt potential.

At American Gold & Diamond Buyers, we evaluate coins based on their collectible and metal values. We serve clients throughout New Jersey and offer immediate payment—with no pressure to sell.

Explore our Coins & Bullion page to learn more.

4. When Is the Best Time to Sell Valuable Coins?

When Precious Metal Prices Are High: Silver and gold fluctuate. Selling during peaks can increase payouts.
During Collector Demand Cycles: Certain coins are popular depending on historical anniversaries or market interest.
When You're Ready: Ultimately, sell when it aligns with your goals. If you work with the right buyer, there's no wrong time.

Final Thoughts: Discover What Your Coins Are Worth

If you've encountered coins and wonder whether they're valuable, you don't need to be an expert—you need the right partner.

Visit American Gold & Diamond Buyers for a no-pressure evaluation. We'll help you identify what you have, explain what makes it valuable, and offer you a fair, immediate payout if you choose to sell.

Turn that forgotten collection or dusty change jar into cash—you might be surprised by its worth.